Friday, 31 August 2012

Topic 3 (who controlls the internet)

TOPIC DISCUSSION 3 (DEADLINE: 5 SEPTEMBER 2012, 12 Midnight)
PLEASE READ THIS ARTICLE:
Who regulates the internet? Personally, do you think there should be internet censorship? Why?
Please read this article:

16 comments:

  1. Actually there is no definite body regulating the internet per se, however the government of a country can regulate it's internet activities but cannot go beyond there border. The US has ICANN and IETF. of which they are a nonprofit private organization, which oversees a number of Internet-related tasks previously performed directly on behalf of the U.S. government by other organizations, notably the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority. So, there is no real body governing the activities of the internet. Like in China, they have censored their internet to a minimum. whereby, one cannot access certain websites.

    Yes i think there should be internet censorship on certain matters. Issues like private affairs of people and nudity. The primary objective of the internet should be for the dissemination of information to people not running into there private lives. what people do with their lives is non of the public's concerns unless its going to harm or benefit the masses. Hence, yes i support internet censorship regarding some issues.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with what you are saying, the internet is a source of information, education, entertainment etc to everybody around the world but unfortunately the internet is also used as a negative tool sometimes. In the interest of peace, security and privacy, the internet should definately be censored to a certain degree.

      Delete
    2. I agree with the both opinions and I think the Internet should be censored in some ways that may not have damages and actually keep the people's privacy as well. that's the point of it but other things except from this point I think its taking the freedom of people to get what information they need ..

      Delete
    3. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    4. absolutely! my personal opinion, i do support the internet censoring only in the highlights matter especially privacy interferes. Yes, the goverment should do internet censoring but in the same time should know the limits of censoring.

      Delete
    5. I also agree, and I'd rather to add there is no clear matter which we can understand, means behind the scene there are so many things that we can't get the specific result, so the thing is going on will not be clear as we expect.

      Delete
  2. The issue of internet censorship has been a hotly debated issue for years now. There are many countries and organizations that support it, likewise many others are against it simply because it is perceived as denying people the right to freedom of speech and information. Personally, I believe that the internet should definately be censored to a degree, many countries all over the world censor their internet so the main issue here is to what degree should it be censored. The internet today is our major source of information but there are certain information that are sensitive and should not be released to the public especially if it is in the publics interest not to know. A typical example is the case of "wikileaks" this site releases numerous top secret and sensitive documents to the general public and although as people we have the freedom and the right to know, this same information could be used to cause significant damage to a country or in the case of an individual, their privacy. Therefore, I support internet censorship but only where it matters and is completely necessary and is also in the best intrest of the public

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What you have said is true, it should be censored to a certain degree. Internet is one of the many media channels that makes the world a "global village", hence as a community we need discipline within ourselves. When internet is censored, it will make a definite demarcation between people's right to know and individual's right to privacy.

      Delete
    2. It is so true and It has been a problem since the governments don't know what are their rights to censor something that the people might want to know and they should know , but as we see there are a lot of countries who actually make their people see what ever they just want them to see and this is not fair because everyone has a right to know what is happening around the world .

      Delete
  3. From the knowledge that I have the governments and politicians around world have this power to regulate the Internet and they can just easily control it but there are also a lot of proxies made to break this filters and censors in the Internet but as I saw there are two different ways of having the internet in the countries , one of them is " The Enemies of Internet " and the other one is "Countries Under Surveillance" the first one is the countries such
    Belarus
    Burma
    China (excluding Hong Kong and Macau)
    Cuba
    Iran
    North Korea
    Saudi Arabia
    Syria
    Turkmenistan
    Uzbekistan
    Vietnam and these are the ones that control the internet and they will not allow their people to see whatever they want to see , for example In my country ( IRAN ) everything is almost filtered , like you tube, Facebook, and a lot of websites that you cant open and see , this is a way that people cant get information from around the world easily although the people use a lot of proxies but still it's so hard for them to get information , and the interesting point is that USA is sending millions of proxies everyday to countries such Iran as well , but generally I don't agree with the fact of censoring the internet except some of the things that are related to the people's privacy and protect their privacies but in any other way of controlling I don't think It's a good idea tojust get the freedom of having an information or get some knowledge from the people

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Exactly, people deserve the right to freedom of speech and information. So whatever steps the governments want to take in censoring the internet it has to be with the approval and the best interest of the people at heart. Internet censorship is a delicate issue and must be handled appropriately.

      Delete
    2. True! the goverment should consider the limitation of censoring the internet. therefore, give the society right of speech and freedom of getting information, and at the same time the privacy issue are protected by the goverment.

      Delete
    3. Indeed it's the truth, and clearly any country is going to cover their own targets with censoring which sometimes is in the right way and sometimes is wrong at all, but personally I think this censoring with any goals mostly will be wrong! cuase people must know the truth, people must know what's going on in their life, that's why the hand that is controlling the censorship will always judge by people around.

      Delete
  4. Debates and question of who regulates the internet it's always there, but the truth is no one regulates internet. That's why all the issue privacy have been interferes.
    Despite however, government should do internet censorship, yet should not exceed the limits.
    The list of county internet "enemies" is actually list of country that have the maximum stage of the internet censorship whereby the usage of internet are minimum.
    But, this goverment also should be considerate limitation of the internet, because society also have the right to be a part of the 21th century where by the accessible data are infinity.
    Personally, i do think that all the goverment need to have internet censorship, where we can get advantages of have the goverment and privacy issues are not publis on the net.
    Thus, it make us feel more save when browsing the net.
    However, government also need to considerate the limitation of internet censorship which on a certain particular matters that are indeed highligts.
    therefore, will be no revolt of society in the future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes the government should consider the masses when censoring the internet, so as to not interfare with their right to free flow of information. The government should censor the internet only as a form of discipline, not for their own selfish reasons.

      Delete
  5. Internet censorship is the control or suppression of the publishing of, or access to information on the Internet. It may be carried out by governments or by private organizations at the behest of government, regulators, or on their own initiative. Individuals and organizations may engage in self-censorship for moral, religious, or business reasons, to conform to societal norms, due to intimidation, or out of fear of legal or other consequences.
    Opinions on the topic of Internet censorship vary, with arguments being made both for and against censorship. Moreover, the extent of Internet censorship varies on a country-to-country basis. While some countries have little Internet censorship, other countries go as far as to limit the access of information such as news and suppress discussion among citizens as Shima mentioned above.
    Blocking and filtering can be based on relatively static blacklists or be determined more dynamically based on a real-time examination of the information being exchanged. All in all personally, I think the censorship never can be the best choice, while I'm sure it's always one of the choices on the table which they never can get it away.

    ReplyDelete